Was F1 given a glimpse of how a reverse-grid race could work?
Was F1 given a glimpse of how a reverse-grid race could work?
No doubt Ross Brawn will have raised a wry smile at what unfolded over the second half of a captivating Italian Grand Prix.
F1 was given a glimpse of what a reverse-grid race could look like as Lewis Hamilton was forced to fight back from a 10-second stop-go penalty through a pack mixed up in the wake of Charles Leclerc's accident that caused a red flag, while AlphaTauri's Pierre Gasly took a shock win.
It was Formula 1's managing director motorsports that proposed the idea of reverse-grid qualifying races for this season, certainly for the second events at Austria's Red Bull Ring and at Silverstone in order to inject spectacle and avoid a repeat of the first races at those circuits.
With unanimity required from all the teams, it was Mercedes motorsport boss Toto Wolff who voted against the idea on the grounds that some teams would try to play "a strategy game" in order to secure pole; that F1 is about meritocracy and does not require "a show format like wrestling"; and that such a concept was "inward-looking" as there was a championship to consider.
Wolff would likely still make the same valid points, but a seed has now been sown as to how exciting F1 could be if it opted to dip a toe in the water of experimentation, with Brawn unsurprisingly making a renewed pledge to implement a reverse-grid race.
If it does not work or proves too unpopular, then at least no-one can say F1 did not try.
Here, GPFans writers Nicholas Quarles van Ufford and Ewan Gale argue for and against the future prospect of reverse-grid races, be it for qualifying or as the main event.
The case for - Nicholas Quarles van Ufford
We are currently in the most dominant F1 dynasty ever. Mercedes has won 95 of the 129 races since the turbo-hybrid era began in 2014. That is a 73.6% win percentage and an average of 14 victories a season! Not even Red Bull’s four-year dominance from 2010-2013 and Ferrari’s six-year run from 1999-2004 come close to that winning percentage.
On Sunday, Pierre Gasly was the first man to win a race whilst not driving for either Mercedes, Red Bull or Ferrari since the opening round of 2013, while the last time those three teams were all absent from the podium was the 2012 Hungarian Grand Prix.
While those are cool stats, it shows F1 has become painfully predictable. In 2020 especially, you know there are only three cars that can realistically win a race, unless…
Unless there was a reverse grid. Sunday’s restart after the red flag was the closest thing we have seen to a reverse grid in F1 - and it was the best race we have seen in a long time.
Hamilton charging hard from the back, overtaking a number of cars as he made his way up from 15th to seventh was captivating, while at the front we had the likes of AlphaTauri, McLaren, Racing Point and Alfa Romeo all squabbling over positions.
Even both Williams cars were right in the thick of it, with George Russell and Nicholas Latifi fighting their hearts out in the hope of claiming the team's first point of the season.
Lastly, look at F2. The junior category has its closest championship fight in years and they only started with reverse grids last year. That is not a coincidence. It just lends itself to more drama, more spectacle, and makes it a better product.
The case against - Ewan Gale
The Italian Grand Prix was the type of race that typifies why we are all captivated by the sport. The monopoly of F1 controlled by Mercedes, Red Bull and Ferrari for so long was broken by a scintillating drive from Gasly, Sainz and co.
But F1 is and should always be a meritocracy. Of course, teams with smaller budgets should be given a fair shot at succeeding, but reverse grids is a step too far. The sport cannot punish teams for performing well, this is not a one-make ‘all-opportunities-are-equal’ championship.
Of course, it was completely foreseeable during the race that talk of reverse grids would be brought up again, but it is a topic I hope will fade almost as quickly as Sunday’s race was turned on its head.
All of the reasons why the race at Monza will be forever remembered would surely be lost if we had similar results week after week.
We had the shock factor of an AlphaTauri battling a McLaren for the win. It would be gone with reverse grids. We had the pure elation of every single team member on Gasly’s side of the garage who will experience this once-in-a-blue-moon event. That, too, would be lost with repeat results multiple times a season.
There wasn't even that much overtaking either, on a track that is basically all straights, with two all-conquering DRS zones and heavy braking zones.
The racing was not that much improved, and we saw a similar amount of decent overtakes as we would in any other race so if we did have this every week people would complain of boredom anyway. Reverse grids? No thank you.
Before you go...
Why Italian Grand Prix victory caps off Gasly's road to redemption
AlphaTauri "can celebrate in December" - Tost
Related
Change your timezone:
Latest News
Audi agree STAR driver contract as Mercedes driver tipped for new F1 seat THIS season - GPFans F1 Recap
- 34 minutes ago
Ferrari show off new-look drivers following HUGE announcement
- 1 hour ago
McLaren leading fight for HUGE cash injection
- 2 hours ago
Newey set to announce STUNNING Red Bull departure
- Yesterday 17:57
Newey Red Bull exit wish CONFIRMED as F1 guru's reasons revealed
- 3 hours ago
F1 legend reveals 'FLOOD' of death threats after controversial decision
- Yesterday 19:57
Related news
F1 reveals viewing figure drop for European based 2020 season
Pirelli boss hails "miracle" despite "nightmare" 2020
Survival the only positive for Haas from dismal 2020 - Steiner
Ricciardo reveals internal pressure for podiums during time with Renault
F1 Standings
Drivers
- Oliver Bearman
- Charles Leclerc
- Carlos Sainz
- Lando Norris
- Oscar Piastri
- Pierre Gasly
- Esteban Ocon
- Sergio Pérez
- Max Verstappen
- Alexander Albon
- Logan Sargeant
- Lewis Hamilton
- George Russell
- Nico Hülkenberg
- Kevin Magnussen
- Fernando Alonso
- Lance Stroll
- Valtteri Bottas
- Zhou Guanyu
- Daniel Ricciardo
- Yuki Tsunoda
Races
- Gulf Air Grand Prix of Bahrain 2024
- Saudi Arabian Grand Prix 2024
- Grand Prix of Australia 2024
- MSC Cruises Grand Prix of Japan 2024
- Grand Prix of China 2024
- Miami Grand Prix 2024
- Gran Premio dell'Emilia Romagna 2024
- Grand Prix of Monaco 2024
- Grand Prix du Canada 2024
- Gran Premio de España 2024
- Grand Prix of Austria 2024
- Grand Prix of Great Britain 2024
- Grand Prix of Hungary 2024
- Grand Prix of Belgium 2024
- Heineken Dutch Grand Prix 2024
- Grand Prix of Italy 2024
- Grand Prix of Azerbaijan 2024
- Grand Prix of Singapore 2024
- Grand Prix of the United States 2024
- Gran Premio de la Ciudad de Mexico 2024
- Grande Prêmio de São Paulo 2024
- Heineken Silver Las Vegas Grand Prix 2024
- Qatar Grand Prix 2024
- Grand Prix of Abu Dhabi 2024
About GPFans
GPFans is a multi-platform, multi-language brand dedicated to Formula One coverage. We bring you all the ins and outs of the sport, 24/7, everything from up-to-the-minute news and features to the latest viral stories and clips.We believe that a new generation of exciting, outspoken drivers will make F1 more popular than ever before, and we want to give our users access to as much of their heroes as possible, on and off the track. From Lewis Hamilton to Max Verstappen, Daniel Ricciardo to Sebastian Vettel, we provide in-depth analysis of every every Grand Prix in the season, from Australia to Abu Dhabi.
With Formula One under the new ownership of Liberty Media, how the sport is being covered is evolving, and GPFans will look to be at the heart of this progression into new media, as one of the fastest-growing sites covering the king of motorsports.
Follow us on your favorite social media channel
Corporate & Media
Innovatieweg 20C7007 CD, Doetinchem, Netherlands
+31645516860