Hamilton v Verstappen - who was at fault?
Hamilton v Verstappen - who was at fault?
Lewis Hamilton's collision with Max Verstappen during the British Grand Prix is one of those incidents that is likely to go down in F1 folklore, mainly due to the violent impact suffered by the Red Bull driver.
It is also an incident you could argue about forever and a day and you will always get a difference of opinion, not necessarily because people want to side with their favourite driver, but due to the nuances these days as to what constitutes a fair and legitimate manoeuvre.
The culmination was a 10-second penalty for Hamilton for causing a collision but was that the right decision?
The GPFans Global team offer their opinions. And you can listen to them debate the weekend here in the latest podcast.
Ian Parkes [chief editor] - The perfect storm
For me, this was a racing incident, as with many we have seen in the past on the first lap, and will no doubt see again in the future.
There can be no doubt Verstappen is aware of Hamilton on his inside as he initially squeezes the Briton close to the wall along the Wellington Straight.
Verstappen then edges over to the left to provide himself with the ideal line to take into Copse. It is at that point that I believe he is convinced Hamilton will back off, yet Hamilton doesn't.
If you watch the onboard of Verstappen's car, at the moment he realises Hamilton is still committed, he makes an aggressive turn of his steering wheel to the right, an almost instinctively defensive manoeuvre, perhaps thinking if he does not do something then he will lose the lead of the race.
It is this sharp steering wheel flick, in tandem with the fact that Hamilton on the inside does not have the ideal line to take Copse that leads to the perfect storm, and the collision occurs.
For the stewards, the fact Hamilton never had his nose in front - he was just a few inches behind at best - heading into Copse, led to them determining the seven-time champion was "predominantly" [note the word] rather than wholly at fault for 'causing a collision'.
As they also only judge the incident itself, and not the consequences, this resulted in their decision that a 10-second penalty was sufficient.
From Hamilton's perspective, the words of his hero, the late Ayrton Senna, spring to mind - "If you no longer go for a gap that exists, you are no longer a racing driver."
Please don't tell me Verstappen would not have done the same if in Hamilton's race boots. This may be the first incident between the pair this season, I suspect it won't be the last.
Sam Hall [deputy editor] - Onus was on Hamilton
Looking at the incident objectively, Hamilton's line for Copse was compromised and there was no way he was going to make it through the corner carrying such speed without making contact, assuming that Verstappen, who held the racing line, was also not going to back out.
In this instance, with Hamilton alongside but never level or ahead, the onus was on the Mercedes driver to back out and although he lifted, the effort to avoid a crash was not enough and a 51g trip to the wall was the result for Verstappen.
Should Verstappen have yielded? No, absolutely not. He held track position and the racing line, as said, so was entirely within his rights to turn in and take the corner.
Racing room was left for Hamilton but, as he had been forced against the wall so had dirty, as well as cold, tyres, the understeer suffered was sadly inevitable.
Incidents like this are always judged in isolation so while there will be comparisons to other comings together between Max, Lewis and others, they are frankly irrelevant in this discussion.
A 10-second penalty was deserved as Hamilton, although not wholly responsible, was predominantly at fault.
The fact he survived and went on to win the race will sting Red Bull but that is racing and were the roles reversed, Red Bull would celebrate such a win with every bit of gusto as was displayed at Mercedes.
At the end of the day, accidents will happen and this, I suspect, is the first of a few this year.
Ewan Gale [F1 writer] - Red Bull may regret insults
As much as I understand the penalty and the phraseology that surrounds it, I don't agree with it.
There was no clear mistake from either party and although Hamilton was most at fault, a line must surely be drawn somewhere to determine racing incidents.
Hamilton was far enough alongside for the move to be considered legitimate and contact between wheels only came as he was backing out.
If he had come from behind, locked a wheel realising his error and taken Verstappen out, then a penalty would be fully warranted.
Whilst he held the racing line, there is an argument that with a 33-point lead ahead of the race, Verstappen may have been better off leaving more of a margin given the perils of the corner, as Hamiton had done previously at Brooklands.
The most important outcome is that Verstappen is healthy and the championship fight can continue, of course, with some added spice.
Related
Change your timezone:
Latest News
Hamilton fired serious warning by Wolff as F1 star takes aim at controversial FIA decision - GPFans F1 Recap
- 1 hour ago
F1's quirkiest star begins selling ICE CREAM in latest venture
- 2 hours ago
F1 colleagues UNFOLLOW each other as internal drama cranks up
- 3 hours ago
Hamilton 'emotional burden' heading into 2024 season revealed
- Yesterday 21:12
Marko DIRECTLY addresses Verstappen quit rumours
- Yesterday 20:27
Vettel CONFIRMS F1 comeback and reveals what's holding it up
- Yesterday 19:42
- 1
F1 Race Calendar
-
GP BAHRAIN
29 Feb - 2 Mar
Max Verstappen
-
GP SAUDI ARABIA
7 - 9 Mar
Max Verstappen
-
GP AUSTRALIA
22 - 24 Mar
Carlos Sainz
- GP JAPAN 5 - 7 Apr
- GP CHINA 19 - 21 Apr
- GP USA 3 - 6 May
- GP ITALY 17 - 19 May
- GP MONACO 24 - 26 May
Related news
British Grand Prix fate sealed in MASSIVE F1 announcement
F1 British Grand Prix 2024: Full guide and ticket details for Silverstone spectacular
Brad Pitt's F1 blockbuster film hits SETBACK after British GP filming
Wolff DEMANDS 'no stone unturned' at Mercedes to stop Red Bull dominance
F1 Standings
Drivers
- Oliver Bearman
- Charles Leclerc
- Carlos Sainz
- Lando Norris
- Oscar Piastri
- Pierre Gasly
- Esteban Ocon
- Sergio Pérez
- Max Verstappen
- Alexander Albon
- Logan Sargeant
- Lewis Hamilton
- George Russell
- Nico Hülkenberg
- Kevin Magnussen
- Fernando Alonso
- Lance Stroll
- Valtteri Bottas
- Zhou Guanyu
- Daniel Ricciardo
- Yuki Tsunoda
Races
- Gulf Air Grand Prix of Bahrain 2024
- Saudi Arabian Grand Prix 2024
- Grand Prix of Australia 2024
- MSC Cruises Grand Prix of Japan 2024
- Grand Prix of China 2024
- Miami Grand Prix 2024
- Gran Premio dell'Emilia Romagna 2024
- Grand Prix of Monaco 2024
- Grand Prix du Canada 2024
- Gran Premio de España 2024
- Grand Prix of Austria 2024
- Grand Prix of Great Britain 2024
- Grand Prix of Hungary 2024
- Grand Prix of Belgium 2024
- Heineken Dutch Grand Prix 2024
- Grand Prix of Italy 2024
- Grand Prix of Azerbaijan 2024
- Grand Prix of Singapore 2024
- Grand Prix of the United States 2024
- Gran Premio de la Ciudad de Mexico 2024
- Grande Prêmio de São Paulo 2024
- Heineken Silver Las Vegas Grand Prix 2024
- Qatar Grand Prix 2024
- Grand Prix of Abu Dhabi 2024
About GPFans
GPFans is a multi-platform, multi-language brand dedicated to Formula One coverage. We bring you all the ins and outs of the sport, 24/7, everything from up-to-the-minute news and features to the latest viral stories and clips.We believe that a new generation of exciting, outspoken drivers will make F1 more popular than ever before, and we want to give our users access to as much of their heroes as possible, on and off the track. From Lewis Hamilton to Max Verstappen, Daniel Ricciardo to Sebastian Vettel, we provide in-depth analysis of every every Grand Prix in the season, from Australia to Abu Dhabi.
With Formula One under the new ownership of Liberty Media, how the sport is being covered is evolving, and GPFans will look to be at the heart of this progression into new media, as one of the fastest-growing sites covering the king of motorsports.
Follow us on your favorite social media channel
Corporate & Media
Innovatieweg 20C7007 CD, Doetinchem, Netherlands
+31645516860