Bird has Hong Kong E-Prix win taken away - was it a fair decision?

Change your timezone:
Bird has Hong Kong E-Prix win taken away - was it a fair decision?
Sam Bird had his victory at the Hong Kong E-Prix taken away after stewards punished the Virgin Racing driver for causing a collision with Andre Lotterer while vying for the lead. But was the decision fair? Opinion was certainly split in the immediate aftermath.
Edoardo Mortara inherited the victory, ensuring the first five races of the 2018-19 season have been won by five different drivers.
Bird, winner in Santiago earlier this year, had appeared to have come out on top, but only after a tense battle with Lotterer left the DS Techeetah man with a costly puncture when he was leading.
After a long wait for official confirmation, Bird was given a five-second time penalty, and lost the win as a result. Check out the incident below and let us know if you agree with the decision on Facebook or Twitter.
The moment Sam Bird made his move.
Was it fair though. It's under investigation? Thoughts?https://t.co/TxuKHaiWpV #BBCFormulaE pic.twitter.com/8uJmuTOBWa — BBC Sport (@BBCSport) March 10, 2019
Sam Bird wins the 2019 HKT Hong Kong E-Prix but is under investigation for contact with @Andre_Lotterer #HKEPrix pic.twitter.com/xMzgo0qSZh — ABB Formula E (@FIAFormulaE) March 10, 2019
YOUR REACTIONS
#FormulaE I think #Bird is a great driver, but his victory in #HongKongEPrix was not fair. Sorry to say, but a driver that causes a collision (with #Lotterer leader at the time) and then wins thanks to that maneuver... is not sport for me. @FIAFormulaE — Giorgio Ferrara (@giorgioferrara) March 10, 2019
#FormulaE I think #Bird is a great driver, but his victory in #HongKongEPrix was not fair. Sorry to say, but a driver that causes a collision (with #Lotterer leader at the time) and then wins thanks to that maneuver... is not sport for me. @FIAFormulaE — Giorgio Ferrara (@giorgioferrara) March 10, 2019
Recommended by the editors
F1 Oscars
F1 Oscars: Lewis Hamilton doesn't have one but Michael Schumacher does
Lewis Hamilton
Lewis Hamilton senses first Ferrari F1 win after breakthrough Chinese Grand Prix
Chinese Grand Prix
F1 Chinese Grand Prix 2026 results: Final classification with penalties applied
Chinese Grand Prix
'Band back together': Hamilton and Bono celebrate on Chinese GP podium after historic race victory

Change your timezone:
Latest News
F1 Oscars: Lewis Hamilton doesn't have one but Michael Schumacher does
- 43 minutes ago
Lewis Hamilton senses first Ferrari F1 win after breakthrough Chinese Grand Prix
- 1 hour ago
F1 News Today: Lewis Hamilton stars at Chinese Grand Prix, F1 winner left in tears
- 2 hours ago
F1 blunder as Kimi Antonelli called the WRONG name on Chinese Grand Prix podium
- 2 hours ago
McLaren BURNED by community note after Chinese Grand Prix
- 3 hours ago
F1 Chinese Grand Prix 2026 results: Final classification with penalties applied
- Today 14:28
Most read
FIA announce late Mercedes penalty verdict after front row lockout at Australian Grand Prix
- 7 march
Lewis Hamilton Chinese GP disqualification a watershed moment for Ferrari
- Yesterday 11:55
F1 News Today: Adrian Newey in firing line as Aston Martin may deliberately DNF
- 3 march
F1 Qualifying Results: Australian Grand Prix times and positions - Verstappen crashes out, Russell dominates
- 7 march
FIA announce Mercedes penalty verdict after Chinese Grand Prix incident
- 13 march
Aston Martin set to DNF at Australian Grand Prix as Alonso and Stroll fear nerve damage
- 5 march





